• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Homebody Eats
  • Home
  • Recipes
    • Appetizers
    • Breakfast
    • Dessert
    • Main Dish
    • Side Dish
  • Entertaining
  • Kitchen Essentials
  • About
  • Start a Food Blog
menu icon
go to homepage
subscribe
search icon
Homepage link
  • Recipes
  • Shop Courses & Cookbooks
  • Italian Cooking Retreat
  • Contact
  • About
×
Homebody Eats » Recipes » Whiskey

Skrewball Old Fashioned (5 Ingredients)

Published: Sep 13, 2021 · Modified: Apr 7, 2022 by Jessica Mode · This content may include affiliate links.

180 shares
  • Share
  • Email
  • Print
Jump to Recipe Jump to Video Print Recipe

Mix together a peanut butter old fashioned cocktail with this Skrewball whiskey drink recipe. With only 5 ingredients, you can create this classic cocktail with a twist.

low ball glass with old fashioned cocktail.

Want To Save This Article?

Enter your email below and we'll send it straight to your inbox. Plus, you'll receive new weekly recipe inspiration.

Save this Article

If you're a fan of the classic old fashioned cocktail, you have to try this modern version.

With flavors of peanut butter, cinnamon, and bourbon, this is the perfect cocktail during the cold months of fall and winter.

This Skrewball whiskey recipe stretches your imagination about how peanut butter whiskey can be used in a cocktail. You have to try sipping on this unique old fashioned recipe. You won't be disappointed!

Jump to:
  • What You'll Learn In This Recipe
  • Bartender Cheat Sheet: 45 cocktail recipes in one guide
  • Ingredients You Need
  • How To Make This Recipe
  • Expert Tips
  • Recipe FAQs
  • More Peanut Butter Whiskey Recipes
  • Skrewball Old Fashioned (5 Ingredients)

What You'll Learn In This Recipe

By making this Skrewball whiskey old fashioned, you'll learn a few bartender tips such as:

  • The benefit of using large ice cubes in spirit-forward cocktails.
  • How to express an orange peel.
  • A simple recipe for making homemade cinnamon simple syrup.

If you're interested in learning more beginner basics about the most popular types of whiskey, check out this liquor 101 video series on YouTube.

You can also sign up for my free bartender cheat sheet to receive a free PDF printable with 45 classic cocktail recipes.

Bartender Cheat Sheet: 45 cocktail recipes in one guide

Want a free guide with recipes for your favorite cocktails? Grab the ultimate cheat sheet for all your bartender needs!

    ​

    Ingredients You Need

    Skrewball old fashioned ingredients with labels.

    You'll notice in this Skrewball whiskey recipe that some elements of the old fashioned are traditional while others are unique.

    • Bourbon: Bourbon is a type of U.S. whiskey made mainly from corn. If you're interesting in learning more about bourbon and other types of whiskey, check out my whiskey 101 post. For this recipe, you're welcome to use your favorite brand of Bourbon.
    • Peanut butter whiskey: There are many brands of peanut butter whiskey available including Bird Dog, Sqrrl, Skatter Brain, Honest Truth, and more. However, my personal favorite is Skrewball.
    • Cinnamon simple syrup: Rather than using a sugar cube like is traditional in most old fashioned recipes, I've opted for cinnamon simple syrup. I think it pairs nicely with the peanut butter whiskey, and it adds a perfect touch of spice. If you're interested in making a homemade version of this simple syrup, check out the recipe notes below.
    • Aromatic bitters: We're keeping this traditional element in order to balance out the flavor of the cocktail.
    • Orange peel: Don't forget to express and garnish with an orange peel. It really helps finish off the drink in an elegant way.

    How To Make This Recipe

    four numbered photos showing how to make an old fashioned with peanut butter whiskey.

    Part of the reason I love this peanut butter whiskey old fashioned is the simplicity of the drink. Here's how to make this cocktail:

    1. Add a large ice cube to a lowball glass. Pour bourbon, peanut butter whiskey, and cinnamon simple syrup into the glass.

    2. Add in two dashes of aromatic bitters. You can think of bitters like salt for your cocktail. They help round out the flavors and give balance to the drink.

    3. Using a bar spoon, stir the cocktail together.

    4. Finally, express the oil of an orange peel over the glass. To do this, use a vegetable peeler to slice off a long peel of the orange.

    Hold the peel over the glass and twist it to release the oil in the peel. This is a great technique that bartenders use to add additional flavor.

    Drop the peel in for an easy cocktail garnish. Then, serve up this delicious Skrewball on the rocks drink.

    Expert Tips

    • Ever wondered why you stir an old fashioned instead of shake it? Cocktails composed fully of spirits should generally be stirred to minimize the amount of dilution. You want the liquor to be the pronounced flavor in the cocktail, rather than having it diluted from ice.
    • Make sure to use a large ice cube in this Skrewball old fashioned. This prevents too much water from diluting the drink.
    • Feel free to adjust the sweetness of the cocktail by adding more or less simple syrup depending on your preference.

    Recipe FAQs

    Can I adjust the sweetness of the old fashioned?

    Of course! Feel free to add more or less cinnamon simple syrup according to your personal taste preference.

    I don't have access to large ice cubes. Can I just use what I have in my freezer?

    A large ice cube is nice because it doesn't melt as quickly, giving you more of the pure flavor of the cocktail. This is popular in many alcohol-forward cocktails. You can purchase large ice cube trays for a reasonable price.

    However, in a pinch, you're welcome to use regular freezer ice. Keep in mind that it will dilute the drink quicker than a large ice cube.

    What does expressing an orange peel mean?

    This is a fancy term that means to squeeze an orange peel over your cocktail. To do this technique, use a vegetable peeler to slice off a long piece of the orange peel. Hold the peel over the glass then bend the peel to release as much oil as possible. Make sure not to break the peel in half so you can use it as a garnish.

    This bartender technique gives you a unique drinking experience. You will be able to smell the orange as you bring the glass close to your nose as well as get a punch of flavor when you sip.

    Can you use simple syrup instead of a sugar cube in an old fashioned?

    Yes, you can absolutely use simple syrup instead of a sugar cube. I prefer to use simple syrup because the sugar has already been dissolved, leaving fewer concerns about having a gritty texture in the old fashioned.

    old fashioned cocktail with large ice and orange twist.

    More Peanut Butter Whiskey Recipes

    If you loved this peanut butter whiskey old fashioned, try some of my other favorite Skrewball drink recipes.

    • two copper cocktail mugs next to Skrewball bottle and orange slices.
      Peanut Butter Whiskey Moscow Mule Skrewball Drink
    • white tropical whiskey cocktail with pineapple garnish.
      Tropical Paradise Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktail
    • peanut butter whiskey shot with Reese's cups.
      3 Ingredient Skrewball Whiskey Peanut Butter Cup Shots
    • espresso martini topped with cold foam and garnished with three coffee beans.
      Peanut Butter Whiskey Espresso Martini

    Love this recipe? Please leave a 5-star ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ rating in the recipe card below. Don't forget to follow along on Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, and Pinterest for more recipes.

    old fashioned in glass cup with orange twist.

    Skrewball Old Fashioned (5 Ingredients)

    Mix together a peanut butter old fashioned cocktail with this Skrewball whiskey drink recipe. With only 5 ingredients, you can create this classic cocktail with a twist.
    Author: Jessica Mode
    5 from 3 votes
    Print Recipe Pin Recipe
    Active Time 5 minutes mins
    Total Time 5 minutes mins
    Course Drinks
    Cuisine American
    Servings 1 serving
    Calories 172 kcal

    Equipment

    • lowball glass
    • jigger
    • bar spoon

    Ingredients
      

    • 1 ounce bourbon
    • 1 ounce peanut butter whiskey
    • ⅛ ounce (¾ teaspoon) cinnamon simple syrup
    • 2 dashes aromatic bitters
    • orange peel for garnish

    Instructions
     

    • Place a large ice cube in a lowball glass.
    • Add in bourbon, peanut butter whiskey, cinnamon simple syrup, and bitters. Stir with a bar spoon to combine.
    • Express the oil of an orange peel over the glass, then drop in for garnish.

    Notes

    To make homemade cinnamon simple syrup add ½ cup granulated sugar and ½ cup water to a small saucepan. Place over medium heat and stir until sugar is fully dissolved. Remove from heat and add in 2 cinnamon sticks. Allow cinnamon sticks to steep for at least one hour, up to 24 hours. Pour into a glass jar and seal tightly. The simple syrup will keep for 1 month in the refrigerator.

    Nutrition

    Calories: 172kcalCarbohydrates: 7gProtein: 1gFat: 1gSodium: 5mgPotassium: 44mgSugar: 6gCalcium: 4mgIron: 1mg
    Have you tried this recipe?Tag @homebody.eats on Instagram so we can see your creations!

    More Whiskey Recipes

    • four Vegas bomb shots in rocks glasses.
      Vegas Bomb (4 Ingredients)
    • four green tea shots in rocks glasses.
      Green Tea Shots (4 Ingredients)
    • Dough Ball whiskey cocktail bottle on top of chocolate chip cookies.
      What to Mix With Dough Ball Cookie Dough Whiskey
    • Skrewball, Sqrrl, and Skatterbrain alcohol bottles on store shelf.
      20 Peanut Butter Whiskey Drink Recipes

    Reader Interactions

    Comments

      5 from 3 votes (2 ratings without comment)

      Leave a Reply Cancel reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

      Recipe Rating




    1. James

      November 28, 2021 at 1:40 pm

      5 stars
      I've made quite a few of the Skrewball recipes on this website and they never disappoint! Really glad I tried this one too. I very unique (and fall like) take on an old fashioned.

      Reply

    Primary Sidebar

    Hi, I'm Jessica! Here, you'll find delicious & fresh recipes that will help you learn to master a new skill in the kitchen!

    More about me →

    Breakfast Recipe Ideas

    • overnight oats in a mason jar topped with strawberry.
      Chocolate Covered Strawberry Overnight Oats
    • cheesy open faced tuna with avocado.
      California Open Faced Tuna Melt
    • three chorizo tacos topped with an avocado slice laying on wooden cutting board.
      Mexican Breakfast Tacos
    • cherry smoothie topped with chocolate granola.
      Cherry Granola Smoothie

    Veggie Side Dishes

    • crispy rosemary baby potatoes in a bowl.
      Crispy Rosemary Baby Potatoes
    • roasted brussel sprouts topped with balsamic glaze and parmesan cheese.
      Brussel Sprouts With Balsamic Glaze (4 Ingredients)
    • blue cheese and almond green beans.
      Almond and Blue Cheese Green Beans
    • garlic cauliflower mash garnished with panko and chives.
      Garlic Parmesan Cauliflower Mash

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    About Us

    Learn About Us
    Privacy Policy
    Accessibility Statement
    Disclaimer
    Terms of Use

    Newsletter

    Sign Up for weekly emails and updates

    Contact

    Contact Us
    Shop Courses & Products
    Work With Us

    As an LTK & Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

    Copyright © 2025 Homebody Eats®

    Pinterest pin labeled as Skrewball old fashioned.

    Rate This Recipe

    Your vote:




    A rating is required
    A name is required
    An email is required

    Recipe Ratings without Comment

    Something went wrong. Please try again.