What To Mix With Peanut Butter Whiskey (30+ Easy Ideas)

Learn the best peanut butter whiskey drinks to make at home. There are many delicious liqueurs, mixers, and liquors that mix well with peanut butter whiskey.

Skrewball, Sqrrl, and Skatterbrain alcohol bottles.

Peanut butter whiskey has become a trendy new spin on one of our favorite spirits, whiskey. Once I tasted peanut butter whiskey for the first time, I knew this liquor could make countless delicious cocktail and shot recipes.

While I've created a handful of peanut butter whiskey shot and drink recipes, I wanted to provide a complete guide for people to learn all of the fun and creative ways to use peanut butter whiskey.

This post will cover lots of ideas about what to mix with peanut butter whiskey. If you have any brilliant combinations that you've tried at home, throw a comment below, so I can try it out too!

While there are many brands of peanut butter whiskey on the market such as Sqrrl, Skatterbrain, and Hard Truth, my all-time favorite is Skrewball. However, any type of peanut butter whiskey you want to drink will work with these recipe ideas.

layered shot with strawberry and peanut butter whiskey.

What You'll Learn In This Article

You'll learn what to mix with peanut butter whiskey, including:

Easy 1 ingredient mixers to shake up with peanut butter whiskey.
A delicious peanut butter twist on classic cocktail recipes.
The best peanut butter whiskey shots to shake up for parties.

Don't forget to check out my other favorite whiskey inspired cocktail recipes.

If you enjoy learning about making cocktails at home, sign up for my bartender cheat sheet. You'll gain access to 45 classic cocktail recipes.

three Skrewball peanut butter whiskey and chocolate shots.

For 1 Ingredient Mixers

If you're looking for an easy, 1 ingredient mixer to pair with peanut butter whiskey, try out these combinations.

Coffee: 1.5 part peanut butter whiskey, 5 part hot coffee, splash of cream (optional)

Hot Chocolate: 1.5 part peanut butter whiskey, 5 part hot chocolate

Apple Cider: 1.5 part peanut butter whiskey, 5 part hot apple cider

Berry Flavored Seltzer: 1.5 part peanut butter whiskey, 5 part alcoholic seltzer

Milk: 1.75 part peanut butter whiskey, 5 part milk of choice (don't forget you can also use chocolate milk)

Coca-Cola: 1.5 part peanut butter whiskey, 5 part Coca-Cola soda

Cream Soda: 1.5 part peanut butter whiskey, 5 part cream soda

Grape Soda: 1.5 part peanut butter whiskey, 5 part grape soda

two copper cocktail mugs next to Skrewball bottle and orange slices.

For Cocktails

Did you know you can make delicious peanut butter whiskey drinks with some tried and true classic cocktail recipes? Here are some of my fun, favorite twists.

Black Russian: 2 part peanut butter whiskey, 1 part coffee liqueur

White Russian: 2 part peanut butter whiskey, 1 part coffee liqueur, splash of heavy cream

Chocolate Martini: 1 part peanut butter whiskey, 1.5 part chocolate liqueur, 1.5 part creme de cocoa, 2.5 part heavy cream

Espresso Martini: 2 part peanut butter whiskey, ½ part coffee liqueur, 1 part espresso, ½ part simple syrup (optional)

Manhattan: 1.5 part peanut butter whiskey, 1.5 part rye, ¼ part Amaro

Mudslide: 1 part peanut butter whiskey, 1 part coffee liqueur, 1.5 part Irish cream liqueur

pineapple and cinnamon garnish on tiki cocktail.

Plus, don't forget to check out some of my favorite peanut butter whiskey cocktail creations:

For Shots

I love Skrewball whiskey for simple shot recipes because it already has so much flavor.

If you're looking for shots made with peanut butter whiskey, check out some of my favorite combinations. Most of these shot recipes only require 2 ingredients.

To make these recipes, combine all of the ingredients along with ice in a cocktail shaker. Shake for about 15 seconds, until everything is well chilled, then strain into your shot glasses.

For a silky smooth shot, be sure to double strain to avoid ice chips.

Caramel Liqueur: 1.5 part peanut butter whiskey, ½ part caramel liqueur. Try caramel liqueur in a PayDay shot.

Vanilla Vodka: 1 part peanut butter whiskey, 1 part vanilla vodka

Coffee Liqueur: 1 part peanut butter whiskey, 1 part coffee liqueur

Raspberry Liqueur: 1 part peanut butter whiskey, 1 part raspberry liqueur

Chocolate Liqueur/Creme de Cocoa: 1 part peanut butter whiskey, 1 part chocolate liqueur/creme de cocoa

Banana Liqueur: 1.5 part peanut butter whiskey, ½ part banana liqueur

Irish Cream: 1 part peanut butter whiskey, 1 part Irish cream

RumChata: 1 part peanut butter whiskey, 1 part RumChata

Cinnamon Whiskey: 1.5 part peanut butter whiskey, ½ part cinnamon whiskey

Reese's Cup: 1 part peanut butter whiskey, 1 part coffee liqueur, 1 part milk

Peanut Butter & Jelly: 1 part peanut butter whiskey, 1 part Chambord

For Boozy Desserts

Believe it or not, peanut butter whiskey is also a great addition to desserts! Here are some of my favorite recipes that taste even better with a little booze.

Ice Cream: If you love peanut butter, you're going to love this creamy, boozy ice cream recipe.

Milkshake: There's not a much better combination than chocolate and peanut butter. These ingredients, plus ice cream, make the base for a boozy milkshake, perfect during the hot summer months.

Brownies: These are the ultimate brownies filled with peanut butter whiskey, topped with peanut butter frosting and chocolate ganache.

Cupcakes: Looking for a fun birthday treat? These peanut butter cupcakes are frosted with boozy buttercream.

Fudge: Combine some peanut butter whiskey into your fudge for a fun holiday treat.

Peanut Butter Balls: If you're a fan of Buckeyes, peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate, you're going to love this alcoholic twist.

milkshake in a mason jar with toppings next to liquor bottle.

FAQs

How do you store peanut butter whiskey?

I prefer to store peanut butter whiskey in the freezer. Super cold peanut butter whiskey makes delicious shots all on its own. However, I also prefer cocktails and mixed shots with super cold whiskey.

The exception to this rule is when you're adding peanut butter whiskey to a hot drink (like coffee or apple cider) or baking with it. I like to keep one bottle at room temperature and leave another in the freezer.

What soda should I mix with peanut butter whiskey?

Here are some of my favorite sodas to mix with peanut butter whiskey:

- Cream soda
- Grape soda
- Dr. Pepper
- Coca Cola
- Ginger ale

What should I mix with peanut butter whiskey?

There are many different liqueurs, mixers, and spirits that mix well with peanut butter whiskey. Here are some of my favorites:

- Hot chocolate
- Berry flavored seltzer
- Cream soda
- Vanilla vodka
- Chambord
- RumChata
- Godiva chocolate liqueur

Be sure to check out the full article for even more mixer ideas.

What's the best brand of peanut butter whiskey?

There are many peanut butter whiskey brands on the market. The best one depends on your personal taste and what you like. Skrewball is my favorite peanut butter whiskey. However, there are many popular brands including Sqrrl, Skatterbrain, Revel Stoke, Ole Smokey, Hard Truth, and Bird Dog, to name a few.

You could also try Ballotin peanut butter chocolate whiskey with these recipes.

More Cocktail Ideas

Looking for even more delicious peanut butter whiskey drinks? Grab my free bartender cheat sheet with over 45+ classic cocktail recipes and see how they taste with some Skrewball or your other favorite PB whiskey.